Popcorn Reviewss

White thumbnail popcorn reviewss
popcorn reviewss banner
White thumbnail popcorn reviewss

The Secret of the Shiledars

Farhad Dalal Founder
By-
Farhad Dalal
Rating
3.5 Star popcorn reviewss

Introduction

One of the reasons that I love cinema is because it has the ability to tell innumerous stories on celluloid. I have always been fascinated by stories right from my bedtime ones by my grandma to my history lessons wherein I was taught of treating the text as ‘His-Story’. Growing up on films like The Da Vinci Code and to a lesser extent Indiana Jones, I did feel that this adventure genre largely remained untapped in the Indian setup. India is a country with a rich history and heritage, something that made me hopeful that it is just a matter of time before someone brings these tales to life. Keeping that in mind, I was quite intrigued by the first look of the new Hindi show The Secret Of The Shiledars, a fictional take involving a treasure hunt dating itself to the Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj era, directed by Aditya Sarpotdar. The concept itself felt so fresh that I was absolutely game going into the show that felt a little staged to begin with, but slowly gathered momentum by transforming into something special!

Story & Screenplay

The little issue that I had with The Secret Of The Shiledars is with the characterization. Based on the novel Pratipashchandra, I really wish its adaptation on celluloid had allowed me to spend a little more time with the character of Ravi (Rajeev Khandelwal) outside the main plot. This could have included his fascination for historic artifacts too (remember, he was still young when his parents had met with an accident), wherein a little more time could have been spent on fleshing out his character. That said, the template of The Secret Of The Shiledars is similar to that of Indiana Jones, wherein the writing that is self aware of the same, also acknowledges it. In its skeleton, it is about the protagonist and his well-wishers having to go from point A to point B in search of a treasure, with multiple obstacles along the way, both in terms of the clues interspersed, and the looming threat with respect to certain individuals. And to the writer’s credit, the drama scores really well with its core.

One thing that the writing gets right is the multiple cultural references with respect to the adventure that is in store for the protagonist and his clan. The starting point of the drama stemming its origins from the throne of Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj to providing information about the Shiledars, or the guardians of the treasure, the writing truly creates the right aura in the drama, just to create ambiguity and intrigue in the minds of the viewers. What it also does is lay the lines of morality with respect to the motives of the characters. For instance, you do know the evil motivations of the character of Ramachandran (Kannan Arunachalam) who claims to be the rightful heir of the treasure. Or even the homely vibe of Dr. Dixit (Dilip Prabhawalkar) and Prashik (Nandu Madhav) who are key catalysts in helping Ravi and his clan, even as the writers briefly keep a couple of characters and their motives under wraps.

The proceedings are interesting given how all the key locations in the drama play their part. This has remained one of they key ingredients for an adventure drama, and it was heartening to see the kind of respect etched with with respect to every location, that itself played an important character in this maze. The little issue that I had was with the fillers in the drama – for instance, the convenient plot points involving the nemesis of the clan randomly dropping on the exact same location during a search op (I understand the information being passed on, but landing on the exact location was a bit of a far-fetched thought), or the ease with which the codes are deciphered, something that was particularly true in the first half of the drama. Even the information with respect to the treasure wasn’t actually ‘unravelled’, but rather presented, something that could have otherwise added a layer of mystery with respect to the characters. But these are still minor flaws, in an otherwise thrilling adventure drama that did tackle some underlying concepts of unity really well.

I was willing to let go of a few flaws with respect to the convenience in the writing, simply because these would ideally classify in the regular trappings of the genre. There was a lot of research that may have gone behind the scenes to link the fictional treasure hunt to actual moments in the history, and that was wonderfully reflective on the screen for which the crew must be applauded. The cultural insights truly won me over by allowing me space to suspend my belief, and completely invest in the journey of the protagonist, filled with obstacles. Hence even the twists and turns in the drama that I could see coming from a mile, didn’t bother me because those remained mere plot-points that were outweighed by the soul of the drama which was the adventure laced with cultural references. The ending also was a satisfying one despite the predictability of the writing. The screenplay here might be marginally convenient but it still accounts for a solid watch.

Dialogues, Music & Direction

The dialogues are insightful with all the cultural references that often lace the narrative, something that adds depth to the drama. For someone who is a fan of history like me, I was completely invested in the theories, clues and the jigsaw maze that tactfully was interlinked in the narrative. The music and BGM is commendable given how the pacy notes have an earthy element to them, something that perfectly highlights the deep-seeded emotions of thrills while grounding the drama in its cultural setup. One of the reasons why the intrigue in the drams is kept intact is because the BGM is a huge contributing factor to it. The cinematography is refreshingly good here, with frames that expertly capture the locations that play key characters in the narrative. Be it the close-up shots of claustrophobia or the beautiful aerial shots, the different shades of the drama are wonderfully represented through the frames. The editing is crisp (at times too crisp for my comfort) while eliminating much of the flab from the narrative that heavily stays focused with its core subject matter. Director Aditya Sarpotdar seems to be an avid admirer of the Indiana Jones franchise, something that he draws his inspiration with a few sequences too. While the characterization could have been better, his world building is intriguing wherein he stays fully committed to the core of the drama. Along the way, the emphasis that he provides on historical artifacts, locations and their significance, truly elevates the drama to the point that it is intriguing. The direction is splendid here.

Performances

The performances are pretty solid by the members of the cast. Harshadaa Kulkarni in a brief appearance stands out with her wonderful screen presence. The stalwarts of the Marathi Film Industry Dilip Prabhawalkar (as Dr Dixit) and Nandu Madhav (as Prashik) lend able support and truly elevate the drama with their immensely earnest acts. Yash Shetty as Prabhudeva and Kumar Kanchan Ghosh as Inspector Mitra (although a little gimmicky but thankfully in control) have their moments to shine. Kannan Arunachalam as Ramachandran is first rate and adds some much needed intensity to the drama. Gaurav Amlani as Aditya fumbles initially with the pitch of his character but slowly finds his mojo and settles nicely into it. Saie Tamhankar as Priyal is wonderfully understated and manages to leave a lasting impression with her measured performance. Ashish Vidyarthi as Pratap is excellent here with a remarkable screen presence, wherein you see the kind of control that he assures with the varied set of emotions that are conveyed through his character. Rajeev Khandelwal as Ravi is top notch once again, and his performance definitely holds your attention throughout the drama. It also helps that much of the drama unfolds through his gaze, and so his level of brilliance can be further measured with the fact that he never went overboard with his emotions. He was well within himself and made for a solid act.

Conclusion

Despite a few familiar trappings of the genre, The Secret Of Shiledars is a solid adventure drama with good performances that makes for an intriguing watch. Available on Hotstar.

Latest Posts

error: Content is protected !!