The Mehta Boys
Introduction
Men are probably one of the most unique creatures on this planet. They are perceived to be strong and masculine with a zero emotional intellect that would supposedly further deprecate on an encounter with an emotional being. But in reality, they are just regular creatures who do not quite know how to express their emotions. But in every relationship, atleast one of the two stakeholders need to have an emotional intellect, which is where men do get away with things – be it their interactions with their mother or sister or spouse. The one dynamics that actually fails more often than not is that of the father and son – seemingly two disconnected individuals who never quite know how to express. It won’t be wrong to say that men actually have invisible walls built around them, that rarely is breached by the same gender. As a result, the strained emotional disconnect between a father and a son remains a global phenomena, sadly.
In a scene in the Hindi film The Mehta Boys, you get to see exactly where the problem lies. You see the characters of Amay (Avinash Tiwary) and His Father (Boman Irani) enter an apartment. The first point of contention for the latter remains on why are the lights on, to which the former replies that he doesn’t wish to be greeted with darkness (probably given his solitude). The scene doesn’t end there – there are hilarious moments that erupt out of these seemingly disconnected individuals alternately switching the lights on and off, while briefly being separated by a wall initially. You can clearly make out that the two individuals aren’t on the same page, but hilariously more so, because you seldom see them communicating their issues with each other (in this case, the ‘light’).
Story & Screenplay
Meet Amay, one of the most organized person living in the most disorganized house. Working as an architect in a reputed firm, the opening shot involves him donning a suit and being presentable for a presentation, even while the dampness on the walls paint a timid picture about his psyche. At his workplace, you see his colleague and ‘girlfriend’ Zara (Shreya Chaudhry) pepping him up before his hig moment. That one little scene is enough to explain the fact that he is under-confident and a reluctant person as far as communication is concerned. And like every boy in this world, he shares a strained relationship with his father. This is evident when Amay has to visit his father and his sister after his mother’s death, that results in an awkward exchange between the ‘men’. And while the original plan remains of his father flying to the US to stay with Amay’s sister, a turn of fate forces Amay to spend time with his father….well for the better or the worse!
The core of the drama remains the searing yet heartfelt relationship between Amay and his father. You see a sense of awkwardness during each of their encounters early on – they are never really in a close proximity with each other. This is true even in their lighter moments with each other – in a scene, Amay’s father casually asks if he’d be interested in eating noodles, to which Amay declines. Yet, during a movie marathon on a rainy April morning, he silently indulges in the noodles while laughing away with his father. In this scene, you again do not see them sitting close to each other – the awkwardness and the lack of communication is pretty much evident. The writing also touches upon the dynamics of masculinity between them – an ego conflict that often results in a distance between two males. In a scene with the duo standing in a lift (probably the only instance wherein the two had to be in a close proximity with each other), are suddenly stranded due to a power failure. In a bid to escape, you see Amay crawling out of a sandwiched enclosure only for his father to exclaim that he will be cut into two. This, while his father doesn’t wish to take any help in getting out of the lift himself. These bittersweet chronicles forge their strained relationship that eventually shapes up with the time that is spent with each other. Incidently, the leaking roof and the tattered cloth are interesting symbolisms to identify with their personality and their relationship. The solution is there in sight but the gap lies in the communication.
One of the most interesting aspects of the drama remains its characterization outside the dynamics of Amay and his father. There is Anu (Puja Sarup) who suddenly has to mould herself to be the ‘female’ of the house after her mother’s death. Usually mothers remain a bridge of communication between the father and the son, but here with her absence, Anu needed to take that mantle. In a scene, after being fed up with all the bickering, you finally see her losing her cool briefly and asking the duo to be civil with each other. In another scene, she unsuccessfully tries to get Amay to speak to their father before budging and doing it herself. You also have Zara who isn’t reduced to Amay’s love interest. There is a sensitive feminine gaze that she brings into Amay’s life even while prepping him for his presentation, or providing an emotional support to him. In a gently moving scene after a major incident, when Amay frustratingly remarks on he can’t understand whether his father is an adult or his child, she gently replies that Amay is the child and he will always be his father. In contrast, Zara gels really well with Amay’s father and invariably becomes an emotional bridge between the two as well.
The drama does get into a niche zone between its second and third acts. You do get to know that Amay has been struggling with his job, just because he hasn’t been able to deal with an authoritative superior. The same traces its roots ‘probably’ from his childhood wherein he couldn’t standup to the authoritative nature of his father. There is an underlying current of grief also, more so on the part of Amay’s father who was close to his wife. He finds himself at a juncture wherein he initially had expected to leave the world before his wife, but sadly finds himself in solitude (unlike Amay who kind of thrives in his solitude). His children are away, he shares a strained relationship with his son, and he is about to be reallocated from HIS home that was the last ‘artifact’ as far as his wife is concerned. And hence, the entire passport fiasco was directed at his grief wherein he didn’t wish to change his address but he was forced to, resulting in all hell breaking loose!
The realisation that forms a major chunk of the subtly moving final act is represented through two major events – one being Amay finally realising his potential and his father’s ideologies of wanting him to think out of the ordinary, that sees him present a completely new design. This, also imbibes the cultural traces in an environment that he has brought up in. Elsewhere, you see his father indulging in a game of cricket wherein he repeatedly taunts a young boy (and his mentee) to ‘bowl like a MAN’. This, until an incident forces him to retrospect his erstwhile behavior towards a young Amay, who may have faced a similar fate as him. I liked how the drama did not offer a complete dialogue between the two – there was still room for improvement when the duo met for the final time. This was a bittersweet ending given that the duo may not meet each other ever, or alternately, a change of heart may see them reconcile. We may never know! But the screenplay comprises of these beautifully heartfelt moments that may not immediately move you, but would sure stay with you long after the film has ended.
Dialogues, Music & Direction
The dialogues are laced with humour and emotions that are brimming beneath the surface. The lines gently convey the underlying emotions while softly tugging the strings of your heart in the most beautiful way possible. The music and BGM are serene and seldom used to manipulate emotions while allowing the rawness of the drama to reach its viewers. There is a gentle and leisurely streak that laces the narrative while effectively enhancing the impact of various scenes. The cinematography often switches between tight close-ups to some breathtaking wide shots – both of which convey a very different picture. The tight-shots allow you to seep into the souls of the characters with respect to the emotions that they wished to convey, while the wide-shots remain the repercussions of their thoughts and actions. For instance, in a scene you see Amay and his father exchanging thoughts of how beautiful it is to sit under the wide sky. The wide-shot a few reels later showcases a wall in the ceiling, conveying this hilarious notion.
The editing is effective in linking the set of emotions from one scene to another although I must admit that there was a brief period of lag in the second hour. Director Boman Irani makes a sparkling debut with a subject that is a universal phenomena. His ability to tap into the emotions brimming under the surface remains one of the highlights of his direction. Also, I liked how there was no spoon-feeding here while allowing frames and the performances to convey the intended emotions. His world building and characterization remained top notch, so much so that it added a sense of relatability to it (I actually did see my equation with my father through the film, we love each other but we just cannot express it). The direction was brilliant while being subtly moving with the intended set of emotions that were presented.
Performances
The performances are immaculate by the members of the cast. Flora Jacob as Flora has her moment to shine in that little scene. Harssh Singh as Sam is superb and really leaves a mark in a scene towards the end. Siddhartha Basu as Sen is sincere, earnest and delivers a dignified performance. Puja Sarup delivers a heartfelt act as Anu, Amay’s sister who is forced to upgrade to the mantle that her mother has left behind. The emotions that she brought to the table with such expressive eyes was enough to moisten the eyes of this little man typing the review. Shreya Chaudhry as Zara is beautifully understated with her act. She is gently assertive while always being mindful of the psyche of Amay and the characters around him. There is a sense of sensitivity that she extracts through her exchanges that really hits home while beautifully acknowledging the feminist presence in the void-stricken lives of Amay and his father.
Boman Irani as Amay’s father comes across as a completely different personality to what Amay may have portrayed him to be in his mind. This is so true, universally speaking wherein we as viewers never really get past the pain and trauma of his father, into fully getting to know him. There is this void that was beautifully represented by a jovial performance while retaining much of the emotions along the way. This was a brilliant performance of the highest order by one of my all time favourite performers. Avinash Tiwary as Amay is so well restrained with his performance. Make no mistake, Amay is a sensitive character that always has longed for that one moment of validation from his father. But unfortunately, his father has similar traits to him that eventually leads to a deadlock and a disconnect. His urge to be respectful is always there but so is his reluctance of having to express to an authoritative figure like his father. It is kind of a vicious circle that the duo represent – by the time you get to know the other person, you are virtually at the finishing line. Avinash was excellent here in conveying yhe intended emotions of his character.
Conclusion
The Mehta Boys represents the bittersweet father-son chronicles packaged in a gently moving, heartfelt and an emotionally stimulated drama that stays with you long after the film has ended! Jeez, this may well be an early contender for the Best Hindi Film of 2025 already! Available on Amazon Prime and Highly Highly Recommended!