The Amateur
Introduction
The title of the English film The Amateur offers an unintentional meta-commentary on the state of the drama that may seem promising on paper but doesn’t fully transform into an exhilarating category on celluloid. There is a reason why the Jason Bourne and the James Bond franchises did work, because it allowed the viewers to shift focus towards its protagonist that was suave and charming while looking beyond the aspects of suspension of disbelief. But the same thought doesn’t necessarily extend to Charlie Heller (Rami Malek) through the film. He seems even more unassuming in the opening sequence when he interacts with his wife Sarah (Rachel Brosnahan), and even offering her to make a quick cup of coffee before she leaves for an overseas assignment. Heller is seemingly a regular average joe working in a 9 to 5 job, until he isn’t. In fact, he is shown to work as a Data Analyst with the CIA, an automatic plot-point that the makers think is enough to extend the suspension of disbelief in the latter stages of the drama. And that is what makes the drama quite predictable and never palpable with tension.
Story & Screenplay
Based on a novel of the same name by Robert Littell, Two of the major conflicts in The Amateur are literally intertwined in the first act. One involves the illegal activities followed by a coverup that some officials of the CIA are involved in, and the second involving Sarah being killed off in a hostage-like situation at her hotel during an overseas assignment. Both these plot-points are directly linked to Heller, with one conflict being personal, and the other professional. The single thought in his mind is of revenge, and of the urge to hunt each of the four assailants down, for which he does request the officials in question, only to turn rogue when they refuse. Hence clearly, The Amateur borrows the principal ideas from films like Taken (2008) while being quite generic with its treatment when it treads the waters of an espionage thriller. The fault lies entirely in the predictability of the plot that doesn’t venture into a zone of unforeseen events at any given point of time.
The proceedings are the most watchable with the writing chooses to focus on the mild politics in the drama, that threatens to shift the power dynamics with respect to its characters. The punch-up technique implied is decently effective even as you witness Heller unraveling a secret, whose strings are attached to a recent attack that transpires in the film. The implications of the plot-point are huge given its co-relation to the geo-politics in play, something that would have been an exciting proposition and a different take on the usual revenge drama. Unfortunately, the writing purely reduces the drama to a simple two-fold cat and mouse chase between Heller, the authorities and the people that Heller is about to hunt down, which makes the drama rather vanilla.
The drama briefly flirts with the character dynamics between Heller and a number of characters. A few of them include his tryst with Hendo (Lawrence Fishburne) and Inquiline (Caitriona Balfe), but literally both these characters are treated as catalysts in the plot, with each of them directly linked to each of the two conflicts in the drama. At a point, the drama is so fleeting with its approach that it just wishes to zoom past multiple plot-points, while never once wishing to pause and invest in the emotional core of the film. This remains one of the biggest letdowns of the film because I wasn’t invested in the pain and agony of the protagonist. In fact at one point, the underlying motive of the protagonist completely disappeared in the wake of his own vulnerabilities to hunt the perpetrators.
I must admit that some of the deaths that were orchestrated did make for an interesting watch. But, because there were no emotions tagged to them, and the stakes in the drama was never raised, the proceedings just felt mid and half-cooked. After a point, you just knew that the protagonist was invincible, a trait that was opposite to the underlying tone of the drama that was cerebral, moody and understated. The suspension of disbelief was an increasingly opposite trait that didn’t necessarily go with the tone of the drama, wherein the results of a few events were directly jumped onto, without moments being invested in how the protagonist managed to ‘hack’ the system. This is true for all major knee-jerk events of death including the half-baked finale that felt decent with its setting but nothing beyond that. And that did sum up the screenplay that was amateur at best while never transitioning into a ‘banger’ category!
Dialogues, Music & Direction
The dialogues are understated but they just lack the punch to infuse life into this rather soulless drama. The BGM did not work on a single theme that was synonymous to the James Bond or the Mission Impossible franchise. It is a different question given that the moods of the two films in question are totally different, in which case, the notes ought to have been directed towards developing an emotional core. The only brief moment of subtlety is when Charlie and Inquiline share a quiet little moment, with both characters having suffered a personal loss. But because that equation wasn’t explored further, it also in turn negated the use of these notes that may have added layers in the narrative. The cinematography essentially comprises of frames that have a gloomy colour grading tagged to them, while being quite flat with the overall outlook of the film. In trying to be understated, the makers probably bartered with the grandeur of the frames too (either that, or the budget was low). The editing was decent while atleast accounting for a slick outlook to the drama. Director James Hawes does a decent job here, however, his broad strokes in direction don’t quite elevate the drama to the desired levels. His focus on relying on the impact of the results more than focusing on the process, is something that lowered the impact of the drama. The detailing was missing while attempting to grab the lowest hanging fruit, and that is why the drama remained ‘amateur’. The direction was mid at best.
Performances
The performances are pretty good although not all characters have a character arc to boast of. Rachel Broshanan as Sarah and Caitriona Balfe as Inquiline are decent although both characters are woefully underwritten. Holt McCallany as Director Moore does a good job although the motivations of his character remained generic and largely unexplored in the context of the drama. Jon Bernthal as The Bear, Barbara Probst as Gretchen, Joseph Melson as Ellish and Marc Rissman as Mishka are decent. Michael Stulbarg as Schiller is average at best and has very little to do. Laurence Fishburne as Hendo is affable and delivers an earnest and sincere performance. Rami Malek as Charlie Heller is nicely understated in his approach, something that was in sync with the tonality of the drama too. But the missing link in his character was the strong presence of an emotional core that didn’t really bring out the pain and angst of his character. This was a good performance overall but not quite memorable.
Conclusion
The Amateur is an amateur spy thriller that never transitions into the ‘banger’ zone. It is decently watchable but also quite hollow and half-baked in a drama that is all vanilla at the end of the day. Available in a theatre near you (from 10th April’25 onwards).