Not Today
Introduction
In a scene from the incredible film The Silence Of The Lambs, Hannibal Lector demands a quid pro quo wherein he offers to exchange clues in return for the personal information of Clarice Starling, a rookee in the FBI setup. Invariably, Clarice opens up on a suppressed emotion of hearing the lambs screaming minutes before being slaughtered, even though she couldn’t do much to help them. It is at this point that the engaging thriller breaks the boundaries of all stereotypes while serving a palpable heartfelt drama even during a brief transition scene wherein Clarice is devoid of any barriers while standing in front of Lector. In a bit of a cinema parallel in the Hindi film Not Today, director Aditya Kripalani masterfully recreates this scenario in a completely different setup featuring two characters that are broken souls, with each of their conversations being a soothing balm for the other. And this reference from The Silence Of The Lambs was a mere starting point of the conversation for Ashwin, a man sitting on the ledge of a high-rise building and contemplating suicide to gain trust in Aliyah, a rookee who has joined the Suicide Prevention Squad oblivious to the knowledge of folks around her. But the twist in the tale is that Aliyah is suffering from depression as well, something that she has repressed within herself for years. But then, does the film Not Today manage to impress with its writing, let’s find out.
Story & Screenplay
Following the aching conversations between two broken souls, Not Today is essentially a dark and pessimistic tale that could so easily have been a drab conversational film revolving around a relevant subject. By this I do mean that the writer’s indulgence in tapping into just the pain quotient of the drama by converting the characters into victims of circumstances just a lurking threat of sorts. But credit to writer Aditya Kripalani for keeping the conversations grounded, expertly blending some light hearted but heartfelt small talks between the two characters that act as circuit breakers while also delving into the lives of common folks like you or me, who might be carrying a mountain of pain within themselves, yet appear to be smiling and happy to the world around them. The conversations are layered by painting a distinct picture of the ever evolving personalities of two individuals that were destined to meet in life, if atleast one of them was willing to give life another chance(which Ashwin did via a phone call).
The drama offers an unwavering focus never losing sight of the current situation of the two characters, while alluring the viewers in their conversations instead of cutting it into a flashback sequence. As a result, you as a viewer are always in the moment with the two characters are never disconnected from their journeys. This trust that the filmmaker does show on his viewers is incredible, as it definitely enhances the overall movie watching experience with a lingering after-effect. The drama wastes no time in introducing the protagonist who is shown to be undergoing training to tackle the various situations that she may encounter during a phone call at the Suicide Prevention Center. In a brief discussion, she briefly retorts on the idea of having to block ‘spam’ calls citing a reason that they may also need help at a latter point. This scene is enough to paint a picture of an unsaid burden that the 24 year old Aliyah has been carrying, even as you are introduced to the other protagonist Ashwin, a 52 year old ex-employee of the Suicide Prevention Center who finds himself at the other end of the spectrum.
I liked how Aditya Kripalani has dealt with the politics around the religion, almost as an underlying layer. Contrary to what is portrayed in the media, the only ‘religion’ prevailing is that of Humanity which is beautifully showcased through the two protagonists of varied fates, yet tied together by the chains of depression, even though they aren’t yet on the same levels of it. The tensions emerging after the first phone call by Ashwin was palpable given that it was also Aliyah’s first day at work, and she was a rookee of sorts. This did work as a boon, given that Aliyah wasn’t too familiar with the chain of events used to tackle the situation, almost doing things that she deemed was right to stop Ashwin from committing suicide. This was particularly true because Aliyah did know what it was to carry a burden of pain and wake up each day, and hence the situation for her may have been relatable(of her earlier trying to commit suicide herself perhaps), only to talk Ashwin out of it. On the other hand, Ashwin has seen life a lot more than Aliyah, yet having lost everything to life with respect to his family members, and the simmering pain originating from each one of them, he finds himself on the verge of ‘taking the plunge’ until his training of being ‘savior’ in the Suicide Prevention Squad coaxes him to make that one last phone call, to give life a final chance.
The POVs are effortlessly switched even as conversations brew and you get to know a little more about the two protagonists, not necessarily with respect to pain but also in their quieter heartfelt moments. The tone of the conversation might be pessimistic but there is a silver lining of hope, even as both look to heal their wounds. I also liked how the city of Mumbai acts as an important character, and almost as a third wheel in the setup. The city that essentially never sleeps has a haunting presence of almost swallowing an individual in the realms of the night, even as the flickering street lights act as guardians of hope, particularly with respect to the two individuals.
This film in many ways is also a spiritual successor to the Anurag Kashyap directed film Kennedy(even though Not Today was made earlier), given how Kennedy had ended. The final act of Kennedy would perfectly fit in here, albeit the character of Ashwin who wasn’t a serial killer by any means, but facing a similar trauma with respect to his family(if not a few steps ahead grieviously so). And with respect to that, the final act here is stirring and captures the essence of the core of the drama, that in a moment of madness, people can take extreme steps yet if you sit back and allow the emotions to calm down, then life has strange ways of providing respite too. And should you take the step of making ‘that’ phone call(even if it were for that final time in your head), you will get to meet another stranger who might also need help. As they say, at times strangers are the best forms of help given that they do not have a baggage to judge, while almost being alternate personalities or extensions of you. Just like Ashwin and Aliyah!
Dialogues, Music & Direction
The dialogues are conversational which might be dark and pessimistic at the core but they definitely have a silver lining of hope, that invariably is the driving force of the lines in the first place. The drama isn’t corrupted by the presence of BGM that would often manipulate the viewers into feeling a certain way. The emotions are raw and so palpable given how you are invested in the respective journeys of the two protagonists. The cinematography is exquisite, capturing frames that are unwavering and do not lose sight of the two protagonists even for a minute. The tight closeups or even the mid-shots help the viewers to get into the psyche of the protagonists, and feel every little iota of their pain, while never willing to dilute its impact by leaving them for a minute. The frames were almost like a meta-reference to viewers who might be suffering from depression in real-life(by blurring the boundaries of the screen), while constantly talking to them through the medium of cinema through the two characters, that adds to the therapeutic nature of the conversations. The editing never abruptly halts the conversations, instead it allows the conversations to flow while the drama ended up being a 90 minute therapy session for me. Director Aditya Kripalani is a genius filmmaker waiting to be discovered(given how he isn’t as talked about as he ought to be). He had a tricky proposition of indulging in the pain of the two immensely well written characters, while also not allowing them to be victims of their respective circumstances. And he blends minimalism with utmost sensitivity, switching POVs masterfully to allow the viewers to spend time with the characters, invest in their journeys while ending the tale on a note that has been long lingering in my mind about the fate of the characters. The direction is splendid wherein Aditya ticks all the right boxes.
Performances
The performances are incredibly good even though this is essentially a two-character story. Vibhawari Deshpande as Mamta has her moments to shine in a character that seems to be disconnected with the kind of impact she could have on the potential victims with suicidal tendencies, while just going through the motions with her job without quite going out of her way to help. But the show belongs to Harsh Chhaya and Rucha Inamdar who essay the roles of Ashwin and Aliyah respectively. Both Ashwin and Aliyah are Yin and Yang in their own way, despite sharing common ground with respect to the pain that they have suppressed. Ashwin is at his tipping point while Aliyah represents hope despite carrying a mountain of pain herself. And in the process, both share a charming chemistry although the two never meet in person, sharing their life stories almost as a rhythmic beat. Rucha is incredibly brilliant while being measured and cautious yet very heartfelt through her nervous body-language and incredible expressions. Harsh Chhaya is such a brilliant actor who could easily infuriate you as Papaji in Undekhi while being the helpless father who has lost his daughter in Kill while being such a natural onscreen here as Ashwin, who has all but lost everything yet hanging in by the thread while allowing life to give him a final chance. His voice modulation seldom reflected of pain to begin with(which is how most folks are, you just cannot tell) but slowly allows a deluge of emotions to take over his persona. This was just a towering act by a performer whose work I am privileged to write on.
Conclusion
Not Today is a therapeutic drama comprising of heartfelt conversations between two broken souls that makes for a brilliant watch. It is so beautifully staged that the drama had lingering after-effects on me wherein I did hope that Aliyah and Ashwin(the two fictional characters in the film depressed in life, that are an extension of you and me) are doing well in life now. Also to anyone who needs help, always remember that there is hope waiting for you at the end of that phone call. This film is Highly Recommended, and I can’t remember the last time that a film has healed me to this extent.