Popcorn Reviewss

White thumbnail popcorn reviewss
popcorn reviewss banner
White thumbnail popcorn reviewss

All We Imagine As Light

Farhad Dalal Founder
By-
Farhad Dalal
Rating
4.5 Star popcorn reviewss

Introduction

The opening film at MAMI, All We Imagine As Light (Grand Prix Award Winner at the Cannes Film Festival) opens with a searing shot of Mumbai, a city that is romanticized by many with regard to its ‘Spirit’. The grim shades of grey and blue followed by a montage featuring unknown voices of the city, paint a different landscape whose fabric is a sharp contrast from what is showcased on celluloid. Within this cramped up city, that is easy to love and even easier to hate, you are introduced to three distinct characters in this mesmerizing tale of longing, love and uncertainty. One of the driving forces of this searing tale lies with its characterization through the gaze of which the drama unfolds, even while using light as a metaphor for hope without being interested in providing any solutions. 

Story & Screenplay

You are introduced to the character of Prabha (literally translated into light) early on, even as she continues with her chores of being a nurse. There is a monotony that you observe in her daily chores, even as she attends a handful of patients or conducts practicals for her juniors. Yet, there is an inherent sadness reflective on her face that you just cannot ignore. The camera shifts its POV to the character of Anu, a carefree junior nurse who is discreet with her relationship that is mostly showcased through quick phone calls, while also preferring to spend most of her meagre salary on things she aspires for. The third wheel in the drama is Parvathy, a character coping with the loss of her husband even while holding fort in her house that is soon vied on by the builders of the city who threaten her to leave the place. And the story essentially follows these characters who incidently belong to different age demographics, and hence, view the city of Mumbai through different lenses.

A key observation with regard to the city of Mumbai, which also plays a character, is the weather where the drama unfolds. The raining season of the city also brings about a wave of stickiness that is reflective on the skins of most characters. The same is in turn a metaphor for the ‘Spirit of the city’ that refuses to lay down but at the same time, over-romanticized with the manner in which it is used as a tool. Come to think of it, each of the three characters are dealing with their levels of insecurity and loneliness, ironically in a city that offers very little space. Here, space is an important ingredient that connects the characters – Prabha and Anu share a cramped up apartment together that just doesn’t provide any privacy (in a scene you see Anu changes her clothes with Prabha in the same room with her face turned away). Anu on the other hand, shares an intimate relationship with her boyfriend Shiaz while being uninhibited in making out in a public park with a bunch of boys playing behind them. Alternately, you see them enjoying intimate bus-rides, all due to a space constraint. This, even as Parvathy is asked to vacate her place, the only space that she could ever call ‘hers’ in a big city.

The politics is an integral element in the drama here, used as a tool at various places that doubles up as a social commentary. If the politics around Parvathy’s flat wasn’t enough by the so called capitalists who are powerful, you also see the society coming together to warn Anu of her boyfriend who happens to be a Muslim, even as the writers perform a balancing act by switching the POV, and focusing on Shiaz asking Anu to dress up in a Burkha in order to come to his place for a night of intimacy while his parents are away. This, even as Anu’s perception about her parents lies in the same breath as that of the society. A brief protest scene also is a clear indication of the class differences that are prevalent in the city. Meanwhile, intimacy is also an important ingredient – you see Prabha longing for intimacy while wrapping an electric appliance around her waste. Yet, most of these plucking issues seem to undergo a sharp tonal change in the second hour of the drama with a change in the setting that takes place.

The grim streets of Mumbai are replaced with the radiant roads of Konkan, that automatically acts as being spacious, a symbolism for freedom as opposed to the shackled lives of Mumbai. The more spacious the new town/village is, the more intimate and closer the camera pans towards the characters that slowly begin to find their voices. There is a definitely sense of realisation despite the odd presence of politics in the vicinity (in a scene outside the city, you see Prabha urinating in a forest too, a stark commentary on the status of Swatch Bharat and the initiative of toilets in the country) that drives the narrative towards its conclusion. The final act is ethereal and psychological at the same time that completely mesmerizes you with the light, which for the first time in the drama is used in its full glory. And even when it is not, and with darkness around, there is a radiance of light surrounding the characters that truly acts as a symbol of hope for a better tomorrow. The screenplay is beautifully penned and makes for a wonderful watch.

Dialogues, Music & Direction

The dialogues are conversational while also usea silences effectively at various points in the drama. The music is soothing and almost an extension of its setting that has a calming influence both on the drama and its viewers in succession. The BGM is equally good and makes a quiet splash with respect to the ambience of the drama. The cinematography offers a fleeting stimulus with respect to the setting. In a scene, you hear Prabha talking about her inherent pain to Anu even as the camera pans to different glimmering windows across the city, implying a similar set of conversations that may potential have transpired simultaneously across various parts of the city. This, even as some beautiful wideshots in a sharp contrast tell a different story with its share of lighting that compliments the frames. The editing is pretty good while maintaining the angst between the characters intact throughout the narrative. Director Payal Kapadia deserves all the accolades in the world for this unwavering piece of direction. She isn’t keen on reaching conclusions or providing solutions, her prowess lies in observing her characters with an unflinching eye that makes for an incredible piece of art that is silently provocative and equally comforting and hopeful. She is brilliant with the exploration of layers in the drama that adds a new dimension here, thereby summing up the direction that is outstanding to the core. And there is something about the representation of intimacy through a female lens….ahhh refreshing!

Performances

The performances are excellent by the brilliant members of the cast. Azees Nedumangad as Dr Manoj is subtly understated as a character that is essentially a loner in the big bad city (with language playing the biggest barrier). His only level of comfort is fighting a battle of her own, thus leaving him to fend for himself with respect to his insecurities. And he beautifully presents his side of the story through a poem. Hridhu Haroon as Shiaz is pretty impressive too, almost being fearful with respect to his future and the role that the society has in store for him. And he does a wonderful job with the emotions that he brings to the table. Chhaya Kadam as Parvathy is a seemingly cheerful character that often keeps her spirits up, both literally and figuratively, despite the challenges in store for her. It is her bit of defence mechanism to survive in a city, and this little dichotomy is beautifully represented in a searing performance of sorts. Divya Prabha as Anu has so many layers to her character who you see as carefree to begin with, but more insecure and curtailed to the norms of the society deep within. She expertly portrays the same through her incredible body language that is also a symbol of freedom (and alternately not depending on the setting). She is simply incredible to witness here. Kani Kusruti as Prabha is just brilliant to the core. Her glum face and seemingly expressive eyes paint a telling picture of the sorrow that she is privy to, while being lonely and longing for intimacy in the big bad city. There is a genuine sense of relatability through her character that is grounded yet on a journey of self-discovery that ultimately resonates the best with the theme of this incredible film. This performance needs to be studied and savoured by all film students.

Conclusion

As a part of our MAMI coverage, All We Imagine As Light is a mesmerizing portrayal of contrasting lives in a layered urban city filled with reclusiveness, that makes for a brilliant watch. This drama comes with my highest recommendation!

Latest Posts

error: Content is protected !!