Raid 2
Introduction
At a point, the searing personality of Amay Pattnaik (Ajay Devgn) in the new Hindi film Raid 2 just faded. At a point, there was no real distinction in the body language of Amay and Singham, both characters that seemingly intertwined by larger nemesis in front of them. At a point, I could hardly tell if the events unfolding were actually a part of this film, or the Singham franchise. For a person with zero context, it would increasingly be difficult to tell the two characters apart – Amay and Singham (atleast the earlier version) are underdogs of the corrupt system who always find a way to win at the end. The difference – Singham is a cop, Amay Pattnaik, an Income Tax Officer. And to think of it, all the vulnerability of the character that was such an important ingredient in touting him as an underdog in Raid 1, made way for a more stylized portrayal of the same character who was simply unrecognizable. And because the story wished to exploit this angle of the character, a seemingly interesting story on paper didn’t quite land onscreen.
Story & Screenplay
First things first – Raid 2 is a lesser product than Raid 1 by atleast a couple of notches. And one thing that distinctly sets the two films apart, us its setting. While the first film almost entirely unfolded in a single setting of a house that is raided by the income tax department, in what turned out to be one of the longest raids ever in the country, the second film has a very scattered setting. The intimidating and claustrophobic setting of the first parts makes way for a scattered location-jumping narrative that doesn’t necessarily typify a raid in the purest sense. The raid itself unfold in isolation, while being loosely connected by a thread that is manipulative, and designed to resemble a Race franchise. People are looking to outwit one another, and then another, and then another – and quite honestly, that remains the trajectory of the film.
The opening sequence comprising of a blaring BGM, nicely warms the viewers by air-dropping them in the middle of a raid that is about to take place. Yet, with power dynamics being exercized the raid also halts until a slow-mo introduction shot of Amay instructing his peers with a glance of his head, is inserted. The motives of the protagonist aren’t necessarily revealed immediately, almost creating a facade of being corrupt more than anything else. As per him, his integrity has outlived his duty of 14 years (the drama takes place 7 years after the events of the first film; it is a natural progression in a way given that Raid 1 was out in 2018). But this unpredictability of the opening act is used as a template throughout the film, something that immensely makes the drama predictable.
One of the biggest roadblocks of the film remain the songs that appear out of nowhere, and stall the flow of the drama. At a point, a happy song in integrated in the narrative almost like a road song that felt like a contrived version of ‘ABCDEFGHI….’ from Hum Saath Saath Hain (1999). It remained odd because the scene prior to it involved Amay’s daughter confronting him for being transferred for the 74th time, citing that she doesn’t have any friends. A few scenes ahead, another song is inserted – this time at a Diwali party, that has no significance to the screenplay. What this does is, suck out the momentum from the drama even when you are introduced to the sweet-talking antagonist Dada Bhai (Riteish Deshmukh) to begin with. In a scene, he really seems to be luring, offering Amay and his wife (Vaani Kapoor) a tour around his property.
Amay remains a fascinating character from the start – someone who is the the darling of the masses, and loyal to his mother whom he often serves by washing up her feet. It is also interesting to note that his mother is oblivious of his ‘crimes’, almost to a point of being sly. The dynamics is an interesting one, even as Amay is hell-bent on reopening the files and exposing the ‘lord’. This contributes to some interesting moments in the first hour, particularly when the discreet investigation is on coupled with the motives of Amay that circles back to the start of the film. The interval block is indeed tense and it does amp up the stakes in the drama during an interesting confrontation that transpires between the worked up protagonist and the calm and calculated antagonist.
But this is where everything starts going south in the second hour which is immensely convoluted, something that just wasn’t needed when all lines are already set. The issue for me was that of the writers trying too hard to take the drama ahead by incorporating twists that are quick and don’t always land. In a scene, even the character of Geeta (Shruti Pandey), a fan-girl of Amay working under him and having a diary of his previous cases, asks him to slow down by saying that her head was spinning. Here, we are witness to two ongoing scams – one that of black money (which is in sync with the title of the film), and two, a case of exploitation of females, a plot-point that had no real business to be in this setup. It was manipulative to a point of turning one character against the other at the end, something that did not land for me. At a point, the game of one-upmanship also resembled the characters of Jewel Thief from last week. New (actually old) characters were introduced only to create an illusion about their motivations before making a flip. The entire sequences were positioned to work for the sheer unpredictability of the plot-points, but because this was used as a template, it all became far too predictable.
The cat and mouse game between the protagonist and the antagonist also wasn’t too different. It refused to settle into the plot and form its core, almost too inclined for the two individuals to continue to outwit one another. Everything felt too cliched, everything was too convenient in a path designed to make the protagonist win (if you think this is a spoiler then you are woefully disillusioned into thinking that the film will end in any other way). There were a few moments of intrigue with the raids being carried out, but this is what the issue of the setting continued to be – the raids never worked outside the isolated space. Even the incorporation of a yesteryear’s number ‘Paisa Yeh Paisa’ is inserted at such a wrong moment, that deviates from the tone of the drama. It almost made the sequence a part of Dhamaal 4 rather than Raid 2, before ending on such a shoddy note with the ‘other’ issue of exploitation catching up. On a side note, the portions involving the character of Rajaji (Saurabh Shukla) out on parole and offering life advice, was a film that Raid 2 should have been! The screenplay here remains a mixed bag while leaving a lot more to be desired.
Dialogues, Music & Direction
The dialogues are crisp and confrontational, something that atleast goes well with the tone of the drama. The music is decent but the songs are so poorly placed that it significantly brings the drama down (even the Tamannaah Bhatia song pops out of nowhere). What works throughout the drama though is the BGM by Amit Trivedi. It is pacy, upbeat and pulsating, something that heightens the drama at regular junctures, particularly in intense ‘raid’ sequences. The cinematography has upgraded to a wider scale, if I were to compare it with the last film. And that isn’t necessarily a good thing. The setting of the house in Raid 1 allowed the camera angles to be claustrophobic with danger lurking in the corner. No such luck here even wherein the presence of ‘danger’ remains scattered, something that is not ideal in a ‘Raid’ film. The editing is decently sharp and manages to hold-up well despite its non-linear structure of jumping shorter timelines.
Director Raj Kumar Gupta is generally a good director who had previously worked his magic with films like Raid and Aamir to name a few. But here, the idea of focusing on the stylized outlook of his protagonist while deviating away from his vulnerable side has backfired. There was moments were the director stamps his authority (like the interval block), but he also gets lost in the convoluted second hour that needed to be simpler. The direction eventually comes across as a mixed bag here.
Performances
The performances are generally good by the members of the cast. Ritika Shrotri, Akanksha Pandey and Ayushi Nema have their moments to shine. Supriya Pathak as Dada’s mother is natural to the core, often sly throughout while tapping into the emotional core of her character pretty well. Sanjeev Jhori as Ashok and Brijendra Kala as Vinay are first rate. Amit Sial as Lallan is a vibe and absolutely the screen-stealer here. Even when the writing isn’t very solid, here is an actor who is able to lift the proceedings to a watchable space just by his performance. Yashpal Sharma also makes his presence felt in an umderwritten character. Saurabh Shukla as Rajaji is terrific and puts forth a commendable act. Shruti Pandey as Geeta is natural to the core and has a solid presence onscreen.
Vaani Kapoor as Amay’s wife is a woefully underwritten character that has very little to do. And the fact that you see her character randomly replacing Ileana D’Cruz from Raid 1, is everything that is wrong with IPs today. The patriarch is left untouched while everyone else remain dispensible. Riteish Deshmukh as Dada Bhai is in terrific form, bringing the right precision of vile and a facade that remain key ingredients to his character. He even emotes beautifully in a searing scene at the end, while bringing in a range of emotions to the table. His performance remained one to savour and cherish amidst the mild ruins of the film.
This brings me to the curious case of Ajay Devgn who plays Singham ‘Again’ here as Amay Pattnaik. This is not to say that he is bad or less impactful but I am appalled of him repeating the same performance using the same expressions, and same body language to convey the emotions. In other words, the versatility of interpreting a performance differently based on the world around him is woefully missing. If someone without a context were to approach this film, he wouldn’t be able to differentiate between Amay or Singham. And that for me is a clutch issue, something that has also creeped into the performances of Salman Khan. The nuances need to be worked on!
Conclusion
Raid 2 is a mixed bag sequel to Raid 1 packaged in a ‘If-Singham-Was-An-Income-Tax-Officer’ Drama that is watchable but doesn’t always land. Available in a theatre near you.