Popcorn Reviewss

White thumbnail popcorn reviewss
popcorn reviewss banner
White thumbnail popcorn reviewss

No Other Land

Farhad Dalal Founder
By-
Farhad Dalal
Rating
4.5 Star popcorn reviewss

Introduction

Basel Adra represents one of the few children, now all grown up in the war-torn bylanes of Palestine. His earliest memory about his activist father remains his arrest while protesting for their land in Masafer Yatta on the West Bank. Clearly, the conflict of the little village remains that of their land cruelty being captured by the Israeli soldiers. As per them, the village ground is solely restricted to their military activities, and that the inhabitations are illegal. As a result, the houses are demolished with pleas being fallen on deaf ears. And this is exactly what the documentary film No Other Land (Oscar’25 Winner – Best Documentary Film) has to offer. The Israel-Palestine war is ‘hopefully’ on its final legs but the conflict between nations is not a topic of recency. In fact, the events of the film are focused on a 3 year period before the war actually broke out, wherein humanity died a million times every single day. As per Basel, there was a brief period wherein the then UK Prime Minister Tony Blair had arrived at their village, that prompted the Israeli military to put a pause on the demolition, before kickstarting the same once things died down. And Basel is just one of the many youths who have been at the receiving end of the trauma that have been imposed on them and their families with a sense of uncertainty of what would transpires in future!

The Good

The rocky terrain of Masafer Yatta is symbolic of the rocky lives of local Palestinians located in the region. Their lives are often restricted to atrocities imposed on them by the Israeli military primarily due to conflicts of land. In a scene you see a woman yelling at the Israeli military that her daughter was trapped in the house which had now been demolished. The response was of utter disdain when they mentioned that ‘they don’t care’. This was one of the many harrowing incidents that were frightening to witness, simply because the basic human trait of empathy and care was missing. The idea of completely stepping away from the human circle is the final nail in the coffin, and the citizens of Masafer Yatta were literally witness to the death of a Godless land. The options were clear – leave the village and settle elsewhere, or stay back and bear the brunt. The idea of rebuilding was negligible given how they had to seek permission from the military (which obviously they wouldn’t provide).

The basic premise of the documentary remains brutal. In a scene, you witness a man being shot simply because he was holding on to the generator which remained a vital tool for the group, even as his helpless mother looked on. That man later was shown to be paralyzed below the shoulder (and later succumbing to his wounds). On celluloid, we have witnessed so many scenes involving gunshots. But this documentary had it documented on camera, that made for a chilling watch while resulting in pandemonium. The degrees of dehumanization doubled up as stakes in the drama, even as the village was witness to water supply being cutoff!

Amidst the atrocities is also a budding tale of friendship between Basel and Yuval Abraham, an Israeli Journalist who is known to fight for the rights of the Palestinians. In a searing moment, you see Basel confessing to Yuval on how he is burdened by his father’s actions while also stating that he isn’t left with enough energy to take things forward. In another scene, you see him exclaiming on how his post hasn’t attracted enough eyeballs, even as its reach remains low. Through and through, you see Yuval being a silent listener and comforting Basel, who spends most of his time on social media making videos of the atrocities. The documentary ensures that it doesn’t paint all Israeli with broad strokes through the character of Yuval, who also joins on the forefront while doing his best to be the voice of injustice. Yet, clearly it is a losing battle even as both Yuval and Basel are subjected to physical blows at the hands of the military, who epitomize the death of humanity.

The Not So Good

Usually, I do criticize the shortcomings of a documentary in this section. But here, the criticism isn’t about the shortcomings but more specifically on how gruesome and chilling the events in the documentary are. From literally a couple of people being shot in close range, to completely ostracizing Palestianian women and children (and even birds and animals, how low can humanity stoop), does indeed classify this documentary as brutal. In fact, it is worth a million nightmares to even think of the atrocities that several people would be subjected to even today (and much more brutal than the events showcased), while I am typing this review. And trust me when I say this, my hands are trembling while recalling the events in the film.

My Final Take

My immediate response after watching the documentary was whether the people (at the very least in the documentary) are actually fine? How are Basel and Yuval doing after filming the final moments of the documentary? More so, are mothers and their children fine? It is just so depressing to witness the lives of people being reduced to rumble, even as the egos of people who matter are put to the forefront. And watching this documentary made me realise on what adverse effects there can be on mankind, often bringing out the worst in individuals. While geo-politics is a tricky subject, it often stems out of a state of power and the will to exercize control, often by meek men who are spineless and pretty much cowards. Yes, war is wrong and if anyone were to tell you otherwise, do not believe them!

I am often a believer of Karma and I see people questioning(at times me included) on why a huge pandemic like Covid-19 created such panic and havoc. And while the conspiracy theories around it might be rife, from the point of view of Karma, I feel one of the major reasons behind it was that humanity has failed to learn from all its mistakes. History has already taught us on why war is wrong, but the question remains….have we learnt anything from it? Is there no moral compass to find solutions to problems? Is this the world that our children deserve, some of whom have already been suffering as seen in this documentary. What is their fault in the war between nations? Can there not be universal brotherhood and learn things from countries like Bhutan?? There is indeed lots to ponder upon as another year ticks by.

I shall leave this here but before that a quiet little thank you to the millions of helpers like Basel and Yuval who do strife to paint the picture of reality while fighting for what is right. And even though they are in the minority amidst the media circus across the globe, they have proven that there can never be a substitute for the truth despite the majority calling things ‘fake’ and ‘baseless'(to suit their agendas and personal narratives). And amidst all this, I am grateful for the life that I am living and for food on my table(touchwood), have never felt more thankful as I have tears in my eyes while typing this.

Conclusion

The winner of Best Documentary Film at the Oscars of 2025, No Other Land is a harrowing nightmare on dehumanization and relentless cruelty recorded in a frightening and bone-chilling documentary that makes for a terrifying watch. This is a documentary that I urge as many people to watch as possible. Highly Highly Recommended!

Latest Posts

error: Content is protected !!