Chhorii 2
Introduction
I am usually bustling with ideas after watching a film, but seldom do I get in this corner with creativity taking a backseat. If isn’t often that I witness such bankruptcy, and much of it has got to do with the new Hindi film Chhorii 2, a sequel to the Hindi film Chhorii (2021) that literally felt like a masterpiece in front of this trash. The themes of interweaving a social message in a horror film has been the common link for films in the Chhorii franchise, like it is in the Stree franchise. But one thing that sets Stree apart is its genre – it is a horror-comedy as opposed to a pure horror. And there is a searing reason for the same – horror films with a social message get so driven by the underlying messaging at times that they end up being woefully dense and heavy, with the allegories being reduced to a hollow object with no identity of its own. And this is exactly what happened with Chhorii 2, something that looked to take the drama organically ahead with a fresh social message but in turn ended up making the same bloody film all over again (and even worse with its filmmaking). This is nothing but a lame and frustrating horror film that aspires to drive home a message but the concept of ‘slavery’ in females at a young age, but it literally falls flat on its face.
Story & Screenplay
It won’t be wrong for me to say that the faltering premise of Chhorii 2 was a lot better than the rest of the film. This doesn’t say much because the moment its central conflict is inflicted, the drama here literally enters a passage of a string of uneventfulness wherein nothing really happens apart from characters running around in confined corridors (and more on that later). When you are first reintroduced to Sakshi (Nushrratt Bharuccha), seven years have already passed from the events of the last film. She is now a school teacher and a mother to a 7 year old girl Ishani (Hardika Sharma) who suffers from skin sensitivity from sunlight. This may seem like a prominent allegory for the film, but it does feel a lot hollow when you see it add up at a later point in the film. The same is true for the lesson of the ‘Caveman’ that Sakshi is shown to be teaching her students. What felt like integral plot-points at the beginning, never quite came together in the folklore.
One of the most weird incidents transpire in the very first act, when you are introduced to Inspector Samar (Gashmeer Mahajani). In an odd turn of events, you see a quick recap veiled as a flashback being narrated by Samar (and not Sakshi), who has allowed Sakshi and her daughter (and Rani their househelp) stay for 7 years in his apartment. Anyone would find this little detail creepy, but Samar is a knight in the shining armour, and drastically different to Sakshi’s thought to be dead but still alive husband Rajbir (Saurabh Goyal). The twist in the tale occurs when a charred facial cut-out of a character appearing in order to lure and kidnap Ishani, while her mother is away. And this marks the point when the film completely becomes tasteless.
There is a drastic shift in the tone that keeps oscillating between a jump-scare horror and an atnospheric horror. Remember the setting of the fields from the first Chhorii, a critical detail that added to the gloomy atnospherics of the drama? The same is replaced by underground wells with corridors straight out of The Dark Knight Rises (2012), only way flatter with the framing and less intimidating. The setting houses a cult group looking to pay their tributes to a ‘Pradhan’ (Supreme Leader) wherein they need a girl from their bloodline to ‘sacrifice’ herself to the divine. What ought to have been a chilling tale of folklore, instead turns into a meandering tale of characters simply running around without much ado, and barely colliding parts.
Something that the sequel deviated from was its protagonist Sakshi, who had so little to do after a point than running around in search of her daughter. In fact, it was the other character of Daasi (Soha Ali Khan), a witch conflicted with her own moralities that wished to give some direction to this frustrating tale. Her folklore and interactions with Ishani did hold some amount of intrigue, but largely was cut-short by the unfocused structure of the screenplay, wanting to give importance to the characters of Sakshi, Rajbir and Samar. Both Rajbir and Samar remained such sketchy characters on opposite ends of the spectrum of morality, that they literally came across as incompetent. Rajbir made countless unsuccessful tries to kill Sakshi, and Samar was literally an incompetent cop seemingly pausing the action for a moment, going on a holiday, returning and resuming an action set-piece that is divided over minutes in the film (and that felt like days while watching it). Literally, neither does the folklore make a splash neither do the characters, all of whom are just shrieking with multiple soulless ‘extras’ in the claustrophobic corridors.
If Chhori 2 was a test match, it would account for its characters playing for a draw by dead-batting and fire-walling any half volley that would come their way. If Chhorii 2 were a reel, I would probably for switched off my phone after leaving it halfway. If Chhorii 2 were a corporate employee, he would have opted for a sabbatical after knowing his fate in his appraisals. In other words, Chhorii 2 is always a losing battle even as it tries to build its atmospherics in the most pale way possible. This sentiment extends even to its final act that didn’t necessarily get the message of feminism across effectively. The film is so emotionally hollow that I am literally out of phrases on what the makers were going for at the end. Neither the mother-daughter bond nor the daughter-witch bond or the viewer-film bond was successful in being established with the film ending abruptly at the end. And that quite accurately summed up a painstaking screenplay that was devoid of creativity and completely bankrupt of new ideas, while wanting to impart a social-message that didn’t make it through. Tch tch…
Dialogues, Music & Direction
The dialogues are so lifeless and after a point I really didn’t care on what the characters were conversing. Neither did the lines build on the folklore nor did they work on the emotional core, stripping the drama of any kind of engagement. The BGM is just so forgettable and poorly executed. Each time a random figure were to appear, the BGM would prepare you for the same. If the thought was to make this a more atmospheric drama, then the idea ought to have been on utilizing the silence in a far more effective manner. The cinematography comprises of frames that lack any imagination or depth. The narrow corridors and claustrophobic passages are marred by frequently tilted frames that made for no impact at all. After a point, even the frames were drab and perfectly in sync with the written material. The editing is quite poor given the amounts of lag that the screenplay possessed. The film was 130 minutes long and about 130 minutes too long! Director Vishal Furia misses the mark by a countrymile. Neither does he score with his world building, nor does he score with his characterization. The entire drama that was stationed to be a folklore with atmospheric horror, was such a drag and a slog because the director did not have a firm grip on the proceedings. It wouldn’t be wrong to say that the film was directionless and the direction was poor, through and through.
Performances
The performances are adequate but none of the characters really standout. Pallavi Patil and Kuldeep Sareen as Pradhan ji are one-note characters that don’t really get a chance to blossom. Hardika Sharma as Ishani does a good job but after a point, her vulnerabilities are never explored. Saurabh Goyal as Rajbir and Gashmeer Mahajani as Inspector Samar are such poorly etched out characters that they come across as incompetent despite both actors being sincere with their performances. Soha Ali Khan as Daasi does a wonderful job despite the writing frequently swaying away from her character. Nushrratt Bharuccha is such a fine actor and I am not sure why she isn’t getting as many opportunities to showcase her talent. Despite the writing treating her as a miscast (tonally speaking when you compare her journey to Daasi’s), she definitely performs well by using her body language and expressions to perfection. Casting Directors – please don’t let this talent wither off!
Conclusion
Chhorii 2 is a lame, frustrating and a soulless (pun-intended) horror that suffers from the creative bankruptcy syndrome. It features such hollow allegories that don’t necessarily convey the underlying social message, making the drama devoid of any kind of emotions. Available on Amazon Prime.