Superman
Introduction
One of the interesting aspects of the new English film Superman, a fresh reboot in the DC Universe remains on how it chooses not to waste time in kickstarting things. As a part of its cold open, we are told that Superman has already made a mark on planet Earth, doubling up as a savior whilst safeguarding his mission of attaining peace from his own planet Krypton that was once home to him and his parents. Even the first conflict of the film appears within minutes of its start – Superman has taken upon himself to stop a war between two fictional countries (a searing reference to the modern geo-political setup of Israel and Gaza) while being defeated for the very first time. In many ways, this reboot ticks the right boxes in making the superhero film more snackable. But it comes with a rider. If I were to view it broadly, Superman like most superhero films hinges on multiple conflicts in a broader good versus evil template, while having nothing new to say by the end of things. It is like visiting a new fast food joint and ordering the full menu, only to realise how you aren’t hungry anymore. It is more of a digestion problem or the stomach’s refusal to digest as many threads in the narrative, as opposed to a single concept which can be simple yet palatable.
Story & Screenplay
The good versus evil template of Superman is certainly backed by good characterization here. So you are introduced to Clark Kent (David Corenswet) who works as a journalist while doubling up as ….you know it…..Superman. The integrity of his demeanor remains paramount given his love for his dog Krypto (or even a fleeting scene involving a squirrel) even as he plunges with a peace-fulfilling mission of stopping a war-like situation between two fictional countries, something that invariably pits him up versus Lex Luthor (Nicholas Hoult). Lex remains an intimidating antagonist in the fray, an Elon-Musk-coded businessman whose sole motive remains to make money and in turn make the United States America a prospering country (familiar plot ehhh?). In fact to counter the prowess of the metahuman entity (read : Superman), he forms soldiers of his own who are doubly powerful and agile. In this good versus evil template, the kind of obstacles that the protagonist faces is itself an interesting watch, something that is cleverly intercut with dollops of humour.
The drama works wonderfully well when it chooses simplicity over gimmicky overstuffed strands in the narrative. For instance, one of the best scenes of the drama includes Clark Kent cooking ‘breakfast for dinner’ as a surprise for Lois (Rachel Brosnahan), his colleague and girlfriend with whom he is celebrating three months of ‘togetherness’. The quirky setting is further enhanced when Clark “allows” Lois to take an exclusive interview of Superman, wherein the latter brings up crisp and razor sharp questions to a now stumbling protagonist. There is a right amount of playfulness that the scene caters to, highlighting the fact that the galactic alien is ‘being human’ after all.
In another scene, the turn of events involving a shift in public perception around the personality of Superman who until then is regarded as a hero, to now labelling him as a villain or a destroyer, is well stationed and staged too. There remains an internal conflict with respect to the protagonist too, that makes him question his own ‘mission’ or goal in life, something that remained an interesting plot-point in the larger scheme of things. But inexplicably, the emphasis never lies on this plot point, or the subsequent political commentary that once remained the building blocks of the drama. There are only fleeting moments of how the presence of social media is used to create opinions, but the impact of it is significantly diluted in the wake of other plot-points that eventually take centerstage.
One of the significant demerits of the writing remains its attempt at incorporating too many concepts at the same time along with too many characters. If there is a ‘black hole’ sequence that literally appears out of nowhere while adding nothing but glitz to the narrative, the presence of too many characters including Green Lantern (Nathan Fillion) or the Hawkgirl (Isabela Merced) sharing a banter on the identity of their group name, or even Mr Terrific (Edi Gathegi) having a sudden change of heart with his want to help the protagonist through the blackhole, or a hot influencer Eve (Sara Sampaio) taking selfies only to accidently reveal a piece of the puzzle. It is too crowded and quite overstuffed, almost making me wonder if there remained studio interference during the writing/production stint of the film.
The repercussions of these convoluted plot-points has a direct impact on the final act too, even though the adrenaline pumping action sequences in the second hour standout. The whole black hole (pocket universe) tie up to the finale meant that Superman steered clear of the actual action that was to transpire on a geo-political arena. There were no signs of a person conflict, particularly after a heartfelt scene involving Pa Kent who has words of wisdom to share. Yes I say heartfelt because the scene clicked, but in the larger scheme of things, the impact remained diluted. Even the final face-off did not arrive too, making this snack bingeable but never quite lingering.
Dialogues, Music & Direction
The dialogues seem to be borrowed from the leftovers of a Marvel movie, typically with the kind of humour it wishes to cater to. The BGM is reminiscent of the 1978 Superman film (a classic in its own right) that immediately evokes a sense of nostalgia, while adding layers to the impact that the theme has on the narrative too. The cinematography is pretty solid for a superhero film, with visuals that are breathtaking and designed to be enjoyed on the big screen. And so is the VFX, that remains top-notch throughout the film. But I couldn’t help but think that the makers did get a little carried away with the frames, that compromised with the simplicity and emotional core of the drama that didn’t really hit the sweet spot for me. The editing is pretty good with solid intercutting shots designed to give you a high during ‘heroic’ combat sequences. This, while also keeping the length of the drama to a shade above 2 hours.
Director James Gunn now comes with a huge reputation following his successful Marvel franchise, The Guardians Of The Galaxy. And you can immediately witness a sense of direction in the DC Universe, of wandering in the quirky territory whilst not quite focusing on the dark tonal setup as in its prior reboot. But, I am unsure if James did get a freehand here given certain plotpoints that just didn’t land seamlessly. The simplicity of the drama that was a trait in the Guardians franchise, is compromised for the ‘glory shot’, that lowers the impact of the drama. The direction here is good but nothing extraordinary here, while remaining consistently in the hit and a miss zone.
Performances
The performances are pretty good by the members of the cast but not all characters have an arc to play with. Skyler Gisondo as Jimmy and Sara Sampaio as Eve are decent here while contributing to the frivolous quirks in the narrative. Isabela Merced as Hawkgirl and Nathan Fillion as Green Lantern share a playful banter but their individual tracks remain heavily skewed in the context of the narrative. Anthony Carrigan as Metamorpho has his moments to shine even while his emotional track remains heavily curated and manipulated. Edi Gathegi as Mr Terrific remains a vital cog in the larger scheme of things, and he definitely makes his presence felt. Rachel Brosnahan as Lois does a wonderful job here while sharing an interesting dynamic with the protagonist.
Nicholas Hoult as the bald-headed Lex Luthor, is quite intimidating and does a solid job. I liked how the antagonist’s track was almost a parallel subplot to that of the protagonist, a rarity in a superhero genre that would use the antagonist in spurts and jerks only. This allowed him to be a worthy nemesis to the protagonist too. David Corenswet as Clark Kent aka Superman is good but several notches below his predecessors Henry Cavill and Christopher Reeve. There is a charm in his personality alright, but his presence isn’t exactly iconic or having an aura around it, that didn’t exactly give me that high in the narrative. He is still good and has his moments to shine but the knockout punch was missing.
Conclusion
Superman is a snackable superhero drama that doesn’t quite linger on for too long. It is good in parts but also overstuffed, thereby making it a decent watch. Available in a theatre near you.