Popcorn Reviewss

White thumbnail popcorn reviewss
popcorn reviewss banner
White thumbnail popcorn reviewss

PI Meena

Farhad Dalal
By-
Farhad Dalal
Rating
2 Star popcorn reviewss

Introduction

It is the final MAMI weekend but before that I did get a chance to squeeze in another show as a part of its regular weekend release. With that, I finished watching PI Meena which is streaming on Amazon Prime. There was a decent buzz around the show given that it was touted as another investigative thriller which usually works if audience are involved in the guessing game. I was also looking forward to watching Tanya Maniktala shoulder the series, an actor who has been making some brave choices in her young and budding career. Now I decided to skip the trailer of the show, and decided to go into the film blind. So then does PI Meena manage to impress, let’s find out.

Story & Screenplay

PI Meena follows the story of a private investigator Meena, a Tamilian working in Kolkata(a fact that had no bearing on the story) who investigates the death of a young man. And during the course of its investigation, it opens a can of worms including a virus outbreak that threatens to spread like wild fire. The story here had the potential to be an engaging thriller given that it also deals with the discovery of another epidemic, like was the case with the brilliant show Kaala Paani. But what sets the latter in a league of its own was its brilliant writing, wherein one event lead to another backed by some wonderful character arcs. And the same is missing in PI Meena that only threatens to explode but never really sets the arena on fire. The screenplay standing at 8 episodes of roughly 30 odd to 40 odd minutes each is decent, but the stakes in the drama are never heightened, while consistently being understated with its approach. As a result, the convoluted drama never really finds its mojo even while showing some promise with its premise.

The drama opens with the introduction of the protagonist who is shown to be a private investigator working for a firm. Soon, she witnesses a ‘hit and run’ accident which results in the death of an individual. What seemed like an accident starts showing traces of being a murder, something that gets the protagonist interested given her traumatic past featuring her brother and mother. But little does she know that the investigation would open a can of worms. The fundamental mistake that the writers have committed is that they try to set the premise at a slightly quicker rate while considerably slowing the drama later on. As a result, the pacing of the drama was a suspect and moments that ought to have given you a high, just fall flat.

The drama is engrossing but only in parts as it switches between being an investigation on a murder and a larger conspiracy that is transpiring. And this wasn’t a bad concept at all on paper but it needed sharper writing and even better execution to truly allow the audience to invest in the drama. Sadly, that was missing as the drama wasn’t focused and a little scattered. Another low for me was the world building and characterization. Speaking about the former, there was a chance to utilize the atmosphere of a hill station by playing around with the fog to generate a sense of intrigue(something that was done well in Jaane Jaan, although the movie was plain average). But the writers were far too focused on the outbreak of a virus, a plot point that never really took off despite having immense potential. And even the character arcs were almost non-existential of all characters, some of whom played the disappearing act in the middle.

The investigation was bland and unnecessarily convoluted for my liking. The thread was spread too thin and as a result, the guessing game was never really on. After a point, it didn’t matter to me who killed the victim, as the writers had by then shifted focus to the viral outbreak only to get back to this plot point that never really felt exciting post that. Even the twists and turns weren’t great despite the body count increasing wherein the drama never really came back together after showing some promise at the beginning. The grand revelation was laughable and the tension in the drama was absolutely missing. To add to the trauma, the story wasn’t concluded either. Overall, the writing has its moments but seemed like a lost opportunity for most of the runtime.

Dialogues, Music & Direction

The dialogues are decently well penned but the bite in the lines was missing. The music and BGM are decent and somewhat succeed in going with the vibe of the drama. The cinematography is good but could have been better had the frames represented the fear by building on the ambience of the drama. The editing is decent as well. Director Debaloy Bhattacharya doesn’t quite hit the sweet spot with the drama. The direction here lacks the execution of a surprise element thrown in the narrative, by significantly mellowing it down. These were crucial moments to heighten the drama, something that did not transpire in the final edit.

Performances

The performances are quite good here and atleast ensure that the drama is watchable. It is still sad that almost all characters do not have a character arc which would have added layers to the drama. Vipin Sharma as Tridip has an element of mystery surrounding his character but it soon fizzles out towards the end although he does a good job. Harsh Chhaya as Pritam is terrific and does a swell job. Jisshu Sengupta as Dr. Rakhaw is wonderful as well and it was a pity that his character wasn’t given enough screen time. Vinay Pathak as Dr. Basu has an inconsistent Bengali accent and he has very little to do apart from the final act which wasn’t executed well either. Parambrata Chattopadhyay as Subho is likable and does a good job here, although his character just doesn’t add up to the overall scheme of things. Tanya Maniktala as Meenakshi does a good job but the writers did not give her enough meat to add layers to her character. As a result, her character is one-dimensional and moves at the same wavelength right throughout. Yet, her presence does light up the screen wherein she manages to impress despite the limitations of her characterization.

Conclusion

The first season of PI Meena had a good concept but the drama never really realises its potential due to some weak writing and poor execution. Available on Amazon Prime.

Other Links

IMDB | WIKIPEDIA | ROTTEN TOMATOES

FEATURED REVIEWS | BLOGS

2023 | 2022 | 2021| 2020 | 2019 | 2018 | 2017 | Home

Latest Posts

error: Content is protected !!