Mitti Ek Nayi Pehchaan
Introduction
In many ways, the protagonist Raghav (Ishwak Singh) acts as a focal point for the contrasting ‘lifestyle’ themes prevalent in the new Hindi show Mitti – Ek Nayi Pehchaan. When you are first inteoduced to Raghav, you see him standing in front of his freshly made presentation in his swanky advertising firm. And yet, you notice that the presentation that he gives (with a ‘gamcha’ on his neck) is about villages in India. The dual nature of the themes is also used as a foresight here – Raghav isn’t someone who has lived in a village outside his childhood, he isn’t even aspirational in that regard. The point being, Raghav doesn’t boast of practicalities of staying or working in a village to qualify him into presenting a point of view from the other side. And this itself remains a fascinating aspect of the drama that sets you up with a little blink into the near future of Raghav, and how his character arc would eventually shape up. And keeping this in mind, Mitti Ek Nayi Pehchaan can also be termed as a rooted story that utilizes the underdog template to really good effect. Interestingly, the hook in the drama remains its emotional core that brings Raghav back to his roots!
Story & Screenplay
Written by Nikhil Sachan, Mitti really scores well with its characterization. While you are witness to Raghav slogging daily in his metro city life and being in a relationship with his girlfriend Stuti (Diksha Juneja), it is the character of his grandfather Sudarshan (Yogendra Tiku) that is used as a catalyst in the drama. As you continue to get acquainted with Raghav who has been aloof for the longest time with his grandparents, only to return on the occasion of the demise of his grandfather, you realise that this is the classic Baghban (2002) template that plays out from the other POV. It doesn’t necessarily villainize Raghav or his inability to receive calls from his grandfather, particularly after falling apart from a heartwarming bond that the duo once shared, while also acting as a streak of realisation for Raghav who has drifted far away from his village life and relations. In his words of his grandfather – Fruits grown in villages would often be sent to the cities, but the trees would be left behind!
In many ways, the farm of Raghav’s grandfather has an underdog story of its own. It is shown to barely be surviving despite a loan taken from a ‘Sahakari Bank’, that sees the origin of Girdhaari (Sharat Sonu) in Raghav’s life. In fact, the key conflict of the field is that of survival after having lost a ‘parent’ of its own. There is almost a parallel plot created that see the field and Raghav on the same pedestal, both having lost a person dear to them, both facing an uncertain future, and both having to deal with the atrocities of the fringes. And interestingly, both their fates are merged when Raghav decides to begin his tryst with modern farming, that sees them both on a journey of highs and lows.
Raghav at the center of things remains a conflicted character too. On one hand, it is his guilt of not making time for his grandparents followed by his late grandfather’s quest to pay off the loans only through the earnings from the farm, that forms an emotional core. On the other hand, his city life featuring his overtly reliant but impatient boss or his loving but accountable girlfriend Stuti, has him sitting on the fence. I liked how the demarcation of the core conflict wasn’t binary for Raghav, in fact it was grey. He didn’t wish to leave his job or his city life while wishing to stay committed to his farm life, unlike say Abhishek (Jitendra Kumar) from Panchayat that remained a victim of circumstances to begin with. In a sharp contrast, Raghav’s close aides and friends Mahoo (Piyush Kumar) and Baiju (Pranjal Pateriya) have a reverse arc to deal with – both have their aspirations to shift and settle in the city.
The classic underdog template kicks in when Raghav takes it upon himself to produce his own crop and pay off the loans through the technique of modern farming. It is almost like a love affair that he shares with his field – as both see are witness to several highs and lows from a Nilgai intrusion to the locust threat, from torrential rainfall to other difficulties along the way. The fleeting perception of rainfall in the highrises of the city and the grassrooted areas of the village, double up as a searing commentary, even as Raghav is showcased to be like a boxer who crops the blows but always finds a way to stand up. I also enjoyed the commentary on togetherness, a trait that is represented through a handful of characters around Raghav including the agricultural officer Kratika (Shruti Sharma) with whom Raghav shares a warm bond.
One of the reasons why the drama also works is because it aspires to break the imagery of a farmer, or for that matter even a modern Indian village that may be stuck in a time loop for most people. The extension of this theme while merging into entrepreneurship along with modern farming techniques is what the writing aims for, and to a large extent the drama works in this regard. You witness the hustle of Raghav, even while being determined to produce flower as a crop and selling it for a price, thereby forcing him to explore alternate options, making his journey inspirational. If anything, the events that didn’t work for me was the final act that felt abrupt and too convenient for my liking, even as the drama refused to offer a commentary on the politics of the village, a point that heavily remained sanitized. And the needless implied love story between Raghav and Kratika, that just marginally deviated from the core of the drama. But overall, the screenplay is committed to being rooted while being heartfelt in many ways.
Dialogues, Music & Direction
The dialogues are understated while offering a contrasting glimpse of Raghav during his interactions with people around him. And yet, there is an inherent sweetness that engulfs the narrative, something that allows you to invest in his journey while being emotionally connected to Raghav through the lines. And the words of wisdom sprinkled through the narrative just hit home! The BGM makes its presence felt by elevating several key moments in the narrative. The cinematography captures the lush green landscapes of the village, while allowing it to be a quiet by-stander in the drama. This, while the mid-shots allow you to stay emotionally connected for most parts of its runtime. The editing is crisp and sharp to the point that the overall length of the drama is kept under check. Directors Gaganjeet Singh and Alok Anita Dwivedi definitely look to stay committed to the underdog template while exploiting it in a rather controlled manner. Their world building and characterization are wonderful, while forming an emotional hook that keeps you invested in the drama for most parts of the runtime. The minor stumble at the finishing line not withstanding, the control that the directors show is reflective in the light-hearted but gripping narrative of the show, wherein the direction remains pretty good!
Performances
The performances are really good by the members of the cast. Kommal Chhabriaa as Shalini gets the body language of her character spot on, while leaving an impact despite a limited screentime. Navneet Gairola as Ashok and Praveen Gaur as Akhilesh are wonderful additions to the cast, and both manage to impress. Sharat Sonu as Girdhaari has a core trait of mischief and he really exploits it with a tinge of humour, something that is enough to trigger you but not enough to hate him (he is only doing his job afterall). And this balance that Sharat treads on, is a sign of a solid performer who understands where to draw the line. Nikhil Jaiswal as Ranjan subtly contributes to the humour of the show while making his presence felt. Devashish Mishra as Sujan Singh, Zia Ahmed Khan as Mahto Kaka, Avinash Shukla as Adhikariji, Mahesh Chand as Charan and Arpit Shashwat as Ajay are first rate in their respective characters.
The primary emotional hinge in the narrative is due to two characters – Sudarshan and Renukaji, and both Yogendra Tiku and Alka Amin remain competent with their emotions. There is a sense of softness to their performances that hits the sweet spot, even while both of them leave lasting impressions in their respective roles. Piyush Kumar as Maahoo and Pranjal Pateriya as Baiju are sincere and earnest with their performances, exploring and nailing the themes of friendship so well through their acts. They maintain an understated yet heartfelt approach that beautifully blends with the whereabouts of the drama, wherein I found myself invested in both these characters.
Shruti Sharma as Kratika has a wonderful screen presence, and there is a sense of vibrancy that she brings to her character. She does manage to do a pretty good job although I did feel that the right pitch for her character ought to have been a fraction lower than what was showcased. But still, she manages to shine here. Diksha Juneja as Stuti is just wonderful to witness here. On any given day, this could have been her story with a shift in POV. The dignity and poise that she brings to her act is superb even while being natural to the core with her emotions and body language. She was a treat to witness here.
Ishwak Singh as Raghav epitomizes a character who is in a rat race to begin with, making his job his whole world with very little space for ‘people’ in his life. You see him mildly scattered when there is no internet connection in his village, or being emotionally distant with Stuti or even his grandmother, while simmering in an internal conflict that would potentially tear him apart. And so typically Raghav remained an underdog, continuing to be understated even whilst having a purpose to fight for. This was the emotional core for the character, and Ishwak really puts his heart and soul into this performance. There is a likeable quality in him that allows you space to invest in his journey, wherein he shines through and through.
Conclusion
Backed by solid performances, Mitti – Ek Nayi Pehchaan is a rooted and heartfelt underdog drama presented as an anatomy of a farm that makes for a wonderful watch. Available on Amazon MX Player.