Caught Stealing
Introduction
There is an unofficial cricketing term by the name of ‘Mankad’, often used for a run-out when a non-striker tries to steal a run in an illegal manner. The sport in the new English film Caught Stealing is baseball but the parallels stay with respect to the protagonist Hank (Austin Butler) – an ex baseball player and an alcoholic suffering from a drug addiction – who gets ‘caught’ in a bit of a mess. In fact, there is a faint reference of ‘stealing’ a homerun right at the start of the film when you see Austin casually watching a baseball match involving his favourite team San Francisco Giants, that prompts itself to be a metaphor for the events that would follow. And yet, the pulpy world of the 90s that you would associate in a film like Pulp Fiction, holds true here too – when the streets of New York remained plagued by gangsters and mobile phones were barely finding their voice amidst the curated chaos. In that regard, Caught Stealing can also be viewed as a black comedy that doubles up as a thoroughly enjoyable spectacle – one that is unhinged and knows exactly what it is attempting with regards to its characters.
Story & Screenplay
Based on the 2004 novel of the same name by Charlie Hudson, one of the interesting aspects of the drama remains its characterization, wherein most characters formulate the fabric and the texture of the drama rather effectively here. For instance, you realise outside the addiction trait that Hank is a green flag, being very close to his mother (who isn’t show until a brief scene at the end), with whom he shares his love for baseball. There is also a sense of regret and guilt infused in his psyche, something that stems from his past involving an accident that not only ended his baseball career, but in the process, also lost his best friend in that incident, something that we get to know in bits progressively throughout the film. And it is ironic on how his intoxication of the past, acts as a connective tissue of his present, even when briefly being distracted during his steamy relationship with his girlfriend Yvonne (Zoe Kravitz).
The black comedy here goes hand-in-hand with the characterization on display – you are introduced to Russ (Matt Smith), Hank’s neighbour whom you first spot leaving to visit his ailing father while entrusting a reluctant Hank with his cat, Bud. It is interesting how Bud plays a similar character as John Wick’s pet, around which the series of events transpire. You also have two Russian gangsters, a Puerto Rico associate, a narcotics detective Roman (Regina King), a couple of Hasidic Drucker brothers – all of whom contribute to the texture of the drama. And in the midst of the chaos, the object of desire remains an unknown key that binds all the sub-plots together.
It is interesting how the Chekof’s gun in the narrative is a harmless key, that connects the dots in the screenplay. In a parallel universe, you would have Sardar Khan from Gangs Of Wasseypur (2012) violently inquiring – ‘Chaabi Kahaan Hai? G@@nd Mein Daale Ho Kya Chaabi’, but then I digress. And yet this key acts as a turning point in the life of Hank, firstly given how he can’t remember where he put it, to even the stakes in the drama being raised with a couple of deaths and a riveting shoot-off that holds your interest in the narrative. In fact, the tone implied is of a black comedy that gives a different dimension to the otherwise standard tropes of gangsters and shootouts, that seem repetitive across many films.
And in the process, you begin to root for the journey of Hank who is often the ‘non-striker’ in a cricket or baseball match, often looking to steal a single or a homerun, while invariably having to face the wrath of many characters – including a kidney rupture, or even commiting an innocent murder along the way. Ironically, a character does tell Hank on how he mustn’t show his teeth if he isn’t going to bite – a perfect anti-thesis of the journey of Hank. The pulpy nature of the proceedings can be determined from the fact that there are so many twists involving murders and shootouts, but the presence of the cops (other than Roman) remains negligible. In a parallel world, the film would be Animal (2023) but then I digress.
One of the criticisms for me lay in the final act, particularly that included the coinciding events of intertwining characters. There was a considerable buildup keeping a potential face-off in mind, and something that could have been unhinged with humour, turned out to be mildly simplistic even though the writing does tie the events together including a call-back scene. Personally, I just wished the drama to end on a massive showdown similar to the finale of Delhi Belly (2009), but that is for another day. Despite the stumble, the journey still remained entertaining and enjoyable.
Dialogues, Music & Direction
The dialogues ooze of the pulpiness that compliments the proceedings of the drama. The BGM heightens the tensions in the drama by elevating the impact of multiple scenes. The notes also add texture to the drama in terms of playfulness that easily extends from the tonal black comedy that is infused in the proceedings. The cinematography comprises of frames that show stillness while depicting the vulnerability of the protagonist, while goes completely bonkers during scenes of shootout or car chases. It is a zany balance that the frames tread on, and the outcome is promising! The editing pattern is taut while cutting through the extra flab, and keeping the overall runtime of the drama in check, so much so that the proceedings are pacy and not repetitive.
Director Darren Aronofsky does A Guy Ritchie here while showcasing his versatility after the sombre and brooding but brilliant film The Whale (2022). I would imagine that he isn’t at his absolute best here, stumbling with his staging in the final act. But even on middling days, the Aronofsky touch is definitely in play, particularly with his world building and characterization that make for a desired impact. His infusion of black humour is impeccable, so much so that he accounts for a enjoyable ride here that is unhinged while definitely making a splash.
Performances
The performances are excellent by the members of the cast. Liev Schreiber and Vincent D’Onofrio as the two Drucker brothers are intimidating and they have their moments to shine. In a sharp contrast, Nikita Kukushkin as Pavel and Yuri Kolokolnikov as Aleksei, the two Russian gangsters have a goofy streak to them that adds a different dimension to the drama. Likewise, Benito Martinez Ocasio as Colorado is a lot of fun to watch and his fate would tickle your funny bone thereby contributing to the humour in the drama. Zoe Kravitz as Yvonne has a radiating screen presence wherein she leaves a mark despite a limited screen time. Matt Smith as Russ is unrecognizable, and he manages to impress here with his unhinged act. Regina King as Roman is understated while being a rather unpredictable character that uses this very trait to drive the narrative.
Austin Butler as Hank is a man in form here. There is a vulnerable side to his personality stemming from his past trauma and guilt, while having to maintain the urgency of his character in the current setting. Austin balances both these aspects rather well while also contributing to the humour quotient in the drama that accounts for a brilliant outing.
Conclusion
Boasting of solid performances, Caught Stealing is a pulpy 90s crime caper packaged as a thoroughly enjoyable spectacle that keeps you entertained through and through.